Sisters Esther and Lizzie are the town matchmakers. But when a new tenant moves into a guest cottage at their Peony Inn, the sisters are shocked to discover that one of them might find a match of her own. Dr. Benjamin Stoltzfus has signed a six-month lease, and Esther and Lizzie are in a surprising competition for the doctor's affections. When Benjamin's granddaughter, Mindy, comes to visit, a young Amish man runs his lawnmower right into her sports car. As Mindy and Gabriel find themselves thrown together time after time, they start making matchmaking plans of their own. As the two put their energy into playing Cupid, it looks like love might also be finding them.