Brynn is living with a roommate, Josh, and trying to adjust to her new single life. At least she's got Carson's Cove, her beloved 2000s teenage soap. The show ended unexpectedly, and main characters Sloan and Spencer never got to declare their love for each other. When a birthday cake shows up on her doorstep, Brynn makes a wish. The next morning, she wakes up in Carson's Cove, and Josh is there too. Except they're not Brynn and Josh, they're Sloan and Fletch. To get home, they have to ensure Sloan and Spencer end up together. But Brynn and Josh start developing feelings for each other. Will they stick to the script, or will real love change the story forever?